Society & Ethics
17 claims · evidence for and against, weighted by source quality
Debate of the day · Society & Ethicsre-evaluated 36d ago
Criminal justice should prioritize rehabilitation over punishment
Leaning yes, with caveats
In the news: Lindsay Clancy mistrial leaves criminal justice students divided over mental health concerns - The Setonian · news.google.com
Supports 54%
Against 46%
Evidence balance — weighted by source quality, not votes · 12 arguments
The question is whether criminal justice should generally organize its response around evidence-based efforts to reduce future offending rather than around punishment severity, while preserving proportionate sanctions an…
Join the debate →
All claims in Society & Ethics
Criminal justice should prioritize rehabilitation over punishment
Leaning yes, with caveats
Political disagreements over Israel significantly strain cohesion within American Jewish families and communities
Mostly yes — with caveats
Surveillance capitalism is the defining economic threat of our time
Depends on scope
Reparations for slavery are justified and feasible
Leaning yes, with caveats
The attention economy is incompatible with democracy
Depends on scope
Meritocracy is a myth that justifies inequality
Leaning yes, with caveats
Cancel culture is a threat to free expression
Depends on scope
Hosting the Olympics increases national pride for at least one year
Depends on scope
High-profile women’s sporting events can match major men’s events in attendance with comparable investment
Leaning yes
Major sporting events can temporarily increase nationalist sentiment
Leaning yes
Legalization of all drugs would reduce overall harm
Depends on scope
Women’s need to work is causing decreasing birth rates
Depends on scope
Privacy as we knew it is effectively dead
Depends on scope
Billionaires should not exist
Depends on scope
Zoos should be phased out
Depends on scope
Social media has made society lonelier despite more connection
Depends on scope
Cities should ban cars from downtown areas to reduce air pollution
Leaning no, with caveats
The evidence moved
Political disagreements over Israel significantly strain cohesion within American Jewish families and communities
Mostly yes — with caveats
Hosting the Olympics increases national pride for at least one year
Depends on scope
Major sporting events can temporarily increase nationalist sentiment
Leaning yes